Fantasy Football show for Sep 15, 2025. Another wild weekend in the books! Fantasy football studs, duds, and takeaways from Week 2! Find out which down performances are a cause for concern for fantasy football managers. Plus, big injury updates, and a look ahead to Week 3! Manage your redraft, keeper, and dynasty fantasy football teams with the #1 fantasy football podcast.
Connect with the show:
Week Two Reflections and Data Gathering
“This is data gathering time, and we don’t want to accept it. We would like to draw conclusions.”
- The hosts emphasize that week two of the NFL season is primarily about gathering data rather than making rash judgments or conclusions.
- While some players may have standout performances, teams often exhibit drastic shifts in performance from week one to week two, which the hosts refer to as “pendulum swings.”
Analyzing Player Performances
“A lot of the best tools of the Foot Clan… don’t even go live until three or four weeks’ worth of data.”
- The hosts highlight the importance of waiting for more data to analyze player performance effectively, mentioning that initial results can be misleading.
- They provide examples such as Derrick Henry, who excelled in week one but flopped in week two. In contrast, players like Jalen Hurts and Josh Allen experienced significant dips in their performance after strong week one showings.
The Eagles and their Tactical Advantages
“The Eagles are 2-0 without a passing touchdown, which should put the fear within.”
- The discussion shifts to the Philadelphia Eagles, noting their surprising performance without notable passing success, attributed to a strong defense and an effective running game.
- They discuss the efficiency of the Eagles’ quarterback sneak play, colloquially known as the “Tush Push,” and express concerns about the legality of how it’s being executed without penalties.
Toughness Evaluation and Player Analysis
“I am just evaluating people on how tough or soft they are.”
- One of the hosts introduces a new analysis style for evaluating players based on their toughness on the field. They are keen to differentiate players who are aggressive and fearless from those who appear to lack grit, signaling a shift in how they critique performances.
- This leads to discussion about Brian Thomas Jr.’s performance and lack of assertiveness, suggesting that he may not be demonstrating the toughness required at this level.
Weekly Highlights of Studs and Duds
“We have a lot to react to this week, and we have studs and duds on the show.”
- The hosts prepare to highlight various standout players (studs) and disappointments (duds) from week two, emphasizing the dynamic and often unpredictable nature of NFL performance.
- They engage in light-hearted banter about puns regarding player performances, showcasing both the fun and competitive aspects of fantasy football enjoyment.
Injury News: Joe Burrow Suffers Turf Toe
“Joe Burrow suffered a grade three turf toe injury that will require surgery.”
- Joe Burrow‘s injury is significant, as he is expected to miss approximately three months, which may lead to speculation about whether he could return for the playoffs. Yet, historical data indicates that this type of injury has a low return rate, with no players successfully returning in the same season after surgery.
- The commentators emphasize that while Burrow will eventually return to play, the severity of the injury—and its violent nature involving ligament and tendon tears—means that he is unlikely to finish the season.
- Reflecting on the Bengals’ current situation, it becomes apparent that without Burrow, their chances of success are severely diminished, affecting the fantasy value of key players like T. Higgins and Jamar Chase.
Fantasy Outlook: Impact of Burrow’s Injury on the Bengals
“Jake Browning will take over, but he’s not incompetent.”
- With Burrow sidelined, Jake Browning will step in as the starting quarterback. While Browning has shown some capability, he cannot replicate Burrow’s performance level, which alters the expectations for the Bengals’ offensive output and players like Chase and Higgins.
- Browning has shown promise in a seven-game stretch back in 2023, achieving a solid average ranking among quarterbacks. However, consistency will be a critical concern, especially with Burrow gone.
- Jamar Chase may still see considerable action since Browning will likely focus on him following the injury, but his ceiling has dropped significantly due to the absence of the starting quarterback.
Other Player Updates and Injuries
“Justin Fields is being evaluated for a concussion and struggled significantly.”
- Justin Fields had a poor performance and ended up in concussion protocol, raising concerns about his availability moving forward. The timing and severity of his head injury could further complicate the Bears’ offensive strategy.
- Aaron Jones also left a game with a hamstring injury, which could open opportunities for other players like Jordan Mason, contingent on the situation with their offensive line. This line has faced multiple injuries, introducing uncertainty for their upcoming games.
- The analysis of various player performances doesn’t just highlight injuries but also underscores the necessity for fantasy managers to remain vigilant regarding matchups and player health as the season progresses.
Impressive Performances in Week 2
“There were some really impressive performances this week.”
- The hosts discuss standout players from Week 2, starting with Jared Goff, who threw for 330 yards and five touchdowns, surprising many with his dominant performance.
- Despite concerns about the Lions’ offense following their Week 1 performance, Goff showcased their potential, indicating that the Lions are a formidable team this season.
Notable Quarterback Performances
“This dude was horrifically bad, and now he’s the league leader in passing yards.”
- Russell Wilson‘s transformation from appearing unplayable in Week 1 to leading the league in passing yards is highlighted with amazement, as he quickly turned around his performance.
- The discussion shifts to the Eagles-Cowboys game, emphasizing the strength of the Cowboys’ defense and the challenges the Eagles faced during the game.
Analyzing Daniel Jones and the Giants
“He looks good. Like, he is handling things really well.”
- Daniel Jones‘s performance is praised, showcasing his ability to manage the game’s tempo, handle blitzes, and make accurate throws across different passing levels.
- The hosts note that Jones has not punted once in two games, which is an unprecedented achievement in the Super Bowl era, hinting at an efficient Giants offense that could play well in upcoming matchups.
“Right now, it looks like… they need Rashi Rice bad.”
- The conversation turns to Patrick Mahomes and the Chiefs, discussing their current struggles, especially in the receiver department, despite Mahomes’ impressive scrambling stats.
- The need for emerging players like Xavier Worthy and Rashi Rice is emphasized, as the team is 0-2, leading to concerns about their offensive capabilities.
James Cook‘s Outstanding Performance
“James Cook was the second highest performer of the week.”
- James Cook made a significant impact this week, proving skeptics wrong by scoring touchdowns at a similar rate as last year. His remarkable run showcased his skill, where he transformed what should have been a loss into a dramatic 50-yard touchdown. This explosive performance cemented his position as the running back one after just two weeks of play.
Other Top Running Backs
“A. Chan, Javante, and Christian McCaffrey round out the top five.”
- The top five performers included standout players such as A. Chan and Javante Williams, alongside Christian McCaffrey, who managed to score nearly 20 points despite the team’s early struggles. McCaffrey’s consistency remains impressive as he continues to be a key player for the 49ers. Meanwhile, Javante Williams’ performance has been notable as he has improved significantly in his second week of play.
The Emphasis on Game Rules and Rookie Mistakes
“Caleb Johnson had a costly mistake on the field.”
- Rookies are still learning the ropes, and some, like Caleb Johnson, faced embarrassing moments due to a lack of understanding of game rules. In a critical play, Johnson, functioning as the kick returner, failed to field a bouncing ball, leading to an immediate touchdown for the opposing team. Such costly errors highlight the challenges rookies face in adapting to the game at a professional level.
Bouncing Back with Bijan
“We are back to Bijan!”
- Bijan Robinson demonstrated his exceptional abilities with an outstanding performance, tallying 22 carries for 143 yards. This performance not only solidified his role as a primary back but also showcased his explosive running ability. The team changed its strategy against Minnesota, leaning heavily on Bijan in the run game compared to stronger pass-catching roles in previous weeks.
The Ups and Downs of Running Back Performance
“Kenneth Walker looks much better in week two.”
- Running backs displayed significant variability week-to-week, with Kenneth Walker rebounding from a poor performance in the first week to deliver an impressive showing with 105 yards and a touchdown. Conversely, other players like Charbonnet struggled, reinforcing the notion that running back performances can fluctuate dramatically based on various factors such as game plan and in-game adjustments.
Early Season Takeaways on Players
“It took me too long, which is two games, but he is absolutely the one for that team.”
- The video discusses the impact of several players early in the season, notably Malik Nabors and Jamar Chase, highlighting how early performances can shape opinions on player value.
- Rome Odunze is pointed out as a standout player, quickly establishing himself as the top receiver on his team within the first two games.
- DJ Moore‘s involvement is acknowledged, reinforcing the potential competition between him and other receivers for the number one spot.
Analysis of Game Highlights and Player Performance
“Devontae Adams, 13 targets. Nice to see.”
- The recap of the weekend’s games reveals that certain players like Devontae Adams had a notable performance, securing 106 yards from six receptions.
- The discussion arises around the challenges of viewing multiple games simultaneously, especially when the NFL schedules a high number of morning games on a single day.
- Puka Nakua is mentioned alongside Devontae, both having strong outings despite some viewing limitations.
Insights on Tight End Rankings and Expectations
“Zach Ertz is the tight end two so far through two weeks.”
- Zach Ertz is emerging as a reliable option for fantasy players, ranking as the second-best tight end after two weeks, bringing attention to the changing dynamics in tight end performances.
- The conversation emphasizes the inconsistencies of other tight ends like Evan Engram and the potential to switch focus to Ertz, who is seeing a significant amount of targets.
- Juwan Johnson’s performance is highlighted, where he has been used effectively in the offense, showcasing his role as not just a traditional tight end but resembling more of a wide receiver.
Disappointments in Quarterback Performances
“Sometimes those starters don’t show up.”
- The video touches on the underwhelming performances of top quarterbacks such as Josh Allen and Jalen Hurts, indicating that poor games happen even to star players.
- The analysis mentions the contexts of their respective games, suggesting that game scripts influenced their fantasy outputs.
- J.J. McCarthy’s struggles are addressed, with the recommendation to exercise caution before starting him in future games, signaling the importance of evaluating players based on broader performance trends rather than a single standout moment.
J.J. Over Goff Experience
“He rushed, he said, into starting J.J. And it ends up going into his lineup over Jared Goff.”
- A player hesitated to start Jared Goff, opting instead for J.J. who did not perform as expected. This decision highlights the risks of fantasy football lineups where personal excitement can lead to regrettable choices.
Concerns About Atlanta’s Offense
“If you want to talk about a situation I would be worried about, it is Atlanta’s passing game.”
- The Atlanta Falcons‘ passing game is showing worrying signs, especially with the quarterback not needing to rely on the pass due to a strong defense and running game. Michael Penix Jr. had limited success, bringing into question the overall strategy and production of the team’s offense.
Breece Hall‘s Performance and Future Outlook
“I’m not going to just write Breece Hall completely off because of one bad game.”
- Breece Hall‘s recent performance was underwhelming, but there is still cause for optimism. He had a significant snap percentage, indicating that he is still a crucial part of the game plan despite a challenging matchup. His earlier performance in week one showed potential, suggesting that one bad game shouldn’t define his season.
Isaiah Pacheco’s Struggles
“Are we panicking about a not top 40 running back?”
- Isaiah Pacheco has underperformed early in the season, which raises concerns regarding his viability as a starter. Despite pre-season optimism about his role, his current output means he may need to be benched until he shows signs of improvement in his performance.
A.J. Brown‘s Underwhelming Start
“Sometimes we overthink it, right? A.J. Brown is still a great wide receiver.”
- A.J. Brown has had a rocky start with low yardage numbers, which might tempt some managers to trade him. However, his talent remains undeniable, and he plays for a strong team. His bout of poor performances underscores the volatile nature of fantasy football, but he is expected to rebound as the season progresses.
“The total passing yards and the total passing attempts opportunities are much better for Brian Thomas.”
- The conversation centers around whether to trade A.J. Brown for Brian Thomas Jr. The argument in favor of the trade is based on the improved potential for total passing yards and attempts for Thomas, highlighting current inefficiencies for Brown.
- Despite a rocky start for Brian Thomas Jr., who has only managed four receptions for 49 yards through two weeks, he still maintains a higher volume of targets than A.J. Brown. There are concerns about Brown’s future opportunities given the team’s overall offensive circumstances.
Receiver Performance Concerns
“The targets, they—I think the passer rating for Trevor Lawrence is 18 when targeting Brian Thomas Jr.”
- Specific statistics reveal that the effectiveness of Trevor Lawrence when targeting Brian Thomas Jr. is significantly low, indicating a poor connection.
- The analysts talk about other wide receivers like Drake London and how their performance affects the perception of Thomas. There is an implication that Thomas might struggle to maintain his role with the emergence of other players like Travis Hunter.
Evaluating Other Wide Receivers and Their Potential
“In a game where they needed him, Hollywood Brown produced five receptions for only 30 yards.”
- The analysis shifts to other players, including Hollywood Brown and JuJu Smith-Schuster. Both had disappointing performances, which raises questions about their current fantasy value going forward.
- The talk about Keon Coleman introduces the idea that he could be a valuable buy-low candidate if fantasy managers believe in his potential, especially after a good week one performance.
The Rise and Fall of Young Talent
“I’m tired of the offseason discussion; I want to see a player that looks 10 times as good as Malik Nabers.”
- Analysts express disappointment in Marvin Harrison Jr.’s performance compared to expectations set during the offseason. His lack of explosive plays raises red flags about his current fantasy viability.
- The commentary stresses the importance of capitalizing on opportunities and maintaining aggressive plays on the field. The mention of other players like Michael Wilson highlights the contrast in talent levels and consistency.
Quarterback Impressions and Team Dynamics
“Joe Flacco‘s got two total touchdowns and three interceptions; he’s taking some sacks.”
- The narrative takes a turn to discuss Joe Flacco’s performance, noting his high volume of passing attempts against tough defenses but also his shortcomings this season.
- Analysts provide insights into how Flacco’s average performance could affect the overall output of his receiving corps. The upcoming schedule against a tough Green Bay Packers defense raises further questions about the consistency of Flacco’s weapons.
Quarterback Assessment and Tight End Performance
“It was like a 40-yard pass, but how many yards did he actually accumulate from it because it was ill-advised and yet worked.”
- The discussion begins with an analysis of a quarterback’s impressive but risky play that resulted in a long-distance pass. Despite the aesthetics of a seemingly far throw, the actual yardage gained was far less, raising concerns about the decision-making process of the quarterback.
- The conversation shifts to tight ends, mentioning several players and their week performances. Sam Laporta, Mark Andrews, T.J. Hockenson, Evan Engram, David Njoku, and Kyle Pitts are highlighted, with a focus on their low reception totals in the current season.
- The hosts debate the reliability of these tight ends, particularly critiquing Mark Andrews for underwhelming performance, suggesting he should be dropped from future consideration, while expressing a degree of trust in Hockenson and Engram.
- The conversation emphasizes the importance of identifying emerging tight end options as many drafted players have not met expectations thus far.
Waiver Wire Alert and Upcoming Show Insights
“It’s a great time to remind you tomorrow is a waiver wire show.”
- As the episode draws to a close, the hosts remind the audience about the next day’s waiver wire show, hinting at the value of this segment for fantasy football management.
- They promote their “ultimate dashboard” tool, which features lineup optimizations and waiver wire assistance tailored to individual leagues. This resource is encouraged for users seeking a competitive edge in their fantasy football leagues.
- They also express gratitude to the audience for their support, reinforcing community engagement through submissions of puns and prompting listeners to follow their social channels for further content.